|
Introduction:
If the government doesn't give the news media information quickly, then the media will get it themselves and frame it for the public before the government gets a chance to put its spin on it, South African journalist Jannie Botes explains.
| |
This rough transcript provides a text alternative to audio. We apologize for occasional errors and unintelligible sections (which are marked with ???).
The Framing of Governmental Information
Jannie Botes
Assistant Professor, Program on Negotiations and Conflict Management, University of Baltimore
| |
So there are a number of other things that we must
remember if we talk about the relationship between journalism and
conflict. One is that conflict is a commodity; it's something that journalists,
for lack of a better term, compete over. I was fascinated a couple of years ago
when Somalia occurred and there was this clan fighting.
The US government
decided to get involved with some troops and also decided that it was going to
send and I've forgotten his name now but it was going to send an Ambassador, I
have forgotten his name, over
to Somalia to basically facilitate, mediate between these clan leaders, early on
in the process. But it was announced on something like a Friday night, I might
have my facts wrong here, but by Saturday morning, both Ted Koppel for ABC, and
I've forgotten whether it was Dan Rather or NBC's Tom Brokaw, were on the ground in
Somalia, interviewing those clan leaders, asking them questions. In my mind this
framed that conflict for the public even before the real mediators got in there
and started framing this conflict, which I just thought was fascinating.
The
media in essence framed that conflict before the real people who were going to
frame it and then tell us about it. Ted Koppel went to the Hill, to Congress and answered
much of the criticism of the media and one of the responses he said was,
"Gentlemen, it's very simple, either you frame it or we frame it, your
choice. If you don't tell us what's going on and we report that or if you leave
a vacuum in any situation the media are going to come in and they are going to
frame it. And they are going to tell people here's what we think is going on.
So if you want things to be framed in a way that you think is right, then you get
out there and tell us. If you don't do it, then we're going to do it, that's just a
natural phenomenon."
|